Man Wins Lawsuit After Medical Error Nearly Kills Him

A Maine jury ruled in favor of the plaintiff, Scott McDonald, in his medical malpractice lawsuit against Mercy Hospital and Dr. James Owens after a medical error nearly took his life in 2003.

The 46 year old man went to the emergency room to be treated for pain he was experiencing from a severe toothache and possible infection.  He informed the ER staff of his allergy to penicillin.  The allergy was also clearly referenced in his paperwork.

Dr. Owens overlooked the warnings and prescribed a medication called Augmentin, an antibiotic that is closely related to penicillin.  Augmentin has been known to cause dangerous reactions in patients who are allergic to penicillin.

After being given the drug, McDonald returned home where he began to swell up and develop a rash all over his body.  The allergic reaction landed him in the intensive care unit for nearly a week.

While the hospital did admit to the medical error, they disagreed with the amount of damages the plaintiff was seeking – $200,000 in compensation and $1 million in punitive damages.  The punitive damages part of McDonald’s lawsuit was dismissed by the judge who stated that the medical error “was not malicious or reprehensible”.

In the end, the jury awarded McDonald $125,000 for his damages.

As patients, we place our trust in doctors to provide us with the highest level of care when we seek medical treatment.  This includes careful review of our medical records and listening closely to our concerns and warnings.  When this is neglected, serious medical errors can result.  If you think you may have been the victim of a medical error that has caused you serious injury or harm, it’s important that you speak with an experienced medical lawyer right away.